Forum

Article on MM training -- reaching out to the Phillipines. 1 Reply

Continue

Started by Ethan B. Miller. Last reply by Ethan B. Miller Dec 1, 2013.

Special Thanks

A special thanks go out to Dr. Bruce Auerbach for his vast and valuable support of the LCDC and the Miller Method for over a decade. Dr. Auerbach will no longer be serving as our VCO liason,  tech…Continue

Started by Ethan B. Miller Sep 9, 2013.

Comparing Applied Behavioral Analysis with the Miller Method

PART ONE


PART TWO

CONTROVERSY AROUND THE ABA/MM WORKSHOP

Recently, Dr. Ron Leaf (ABA) complained to Dr. Miller (MM) about alleged bias in the structure of the recent workshop comparing ABA with the Miller Method. By implication he challenged the authenticity of the findings which showed the MM to have a more significant impact than ABA on the nonverbal autistic child both approaches worked with. Below, is the exchange between Dr. Leaf and Dr. Miller. Dr. Leaf: It's the issue of fairness. We found the workshop to be set up in such a biased manner. Not only was the division of time not equitable but the fact that Dr. Miller had contact with clients prior to the workshop was once more example of not abiding by the "agreement". I can certainly understand that he needed every possible advantage but I was disappointed nonetheless.

Dr. Miller: Ron, I take strong exception to your assertion that the workshop was biased in favor of the Miller Method. If anything, the workshop was strongly biased in favor of ABA! It was at your request that we authorized Toby Mountjoy (Dr. Leaf’s associate) to have 4 additional hours "off stage" with each child so that you might demonstrate gains achieved at the end of the third day. Since each of us had a videotaped hour with each child, with Toby's extra hours that amounted to a 5:1 ratio of hours to be spent with each child by ABA...While the unfairness implicit in this arrangement was troublesome, I went along with it in the interest of getting the workshop off the ground.

You also made the following comment: "...but the fact that Dr. Miller had contact with clients prior to the workshop was once more example of not abiding by the "agreement".

What in the world are you referring to?: Of course we had prior e-mail contact with potential volunteers for the workshop. How else were we to screen so that inappropriate children, e.g., those with seizure disorders, were not included. At no time did we have face-to-face contact with the children or parents until they actually appeared at the workshop.

I am troubled by your penchant for distorting the facts. Is it possible that you find it difficult to accept the obvious, i.e., that the MM "a miscellaneous approach" (your words), was a vastly superior method than ABA for helping nonverbal children on the autism spectrum make progress? Frankly, given the gusto with which you sought to dispose of other approaches, I expected much more from ABA. Instead I found a naivete re developmental issues, e.g., trying to teach a child functioning at 13-14 months how to make choices, as well as what it takes to develop meaningful communication other than by trying to get an echolalic child attach significance to remote terms such as "helicopter."

Dr. Leaf: Very entertaining…

Dr. Miller: I’m glad that you enjoyed my response to your allegations of bias. However, I do not enjoy having my integrity and the integrity of my work, questioned…I will accept an apology from you and let this matter drop.

The Miller Method® refers to a unique method for treating children on the autism spectrum as well as those with severe developmental issues.

Photos

Loading…
  • Add Photos
  • View All

Latest Activity

Ritchie Leonard posted events
1 hour ago
Ritchie Leonard posted a status
5 hours ago
Ritchie Leonard posted a status
9 hours ago
Ritchie Leonard posted a status
14 hours ago

Videos

  • Add Videos
  • View All
 
 
 

Technical support is available for video conferencing

Technical support is available for video conferencing with Dr. Miller and the LCDC. If you are unable to connect a video call with Dr. Miller, please call Dr. Miller directly to let him know. You may also call me directly. If I am unavailable when you call, please leave a message and I will try to get back to you as soon as possible.

If you have a general question about video conferencing, please click on the “contact drbruce” link below, and send me an e-mail. I will respond to your questions by e-mail, generally within two days. I may also post answers on a FAQ page, if they are likely to be of general interest.
Contact Dr.Bruce

or email me at drbruce@comcast.net

Members

Join Us on Facebook

Come Like Us On Facebook

© 2014   Created by Jonathan Thurston.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service